- in my view, it would be better to first describe how SPARTA comes to realize there is a dual-use item or development? that is to some extent already described in Chapter 4 (and in the CA): the ethics committee is monitoring what's going on in SPARTA and
reacts to notifications from partners.
The EC guidelines are helpful in this regard.
- then follows section 2.2 actions within SPARTA. That section is very succinct, but perhaps sufficient since we have the rules in the CA.
Yes.
- before notifying, some national authorities (Chapter 3) wouldn't we try to solve the problem internally? Could a system be designed differently to avoid dual use? That should be priority 1.
I agree.
- in case that dual-use is unavoidable (or even intended) which national authority should be contacted? In which country? Do we know what authority this would be (for Germany I have to admit: I do not know...).
Should
we try to set up the list for this?
- and as I said in the beginning apart from the 4 solutions sketched it could be that a development could also be terminated.
Best
Michael
--
Dr. Michael Friedewald
Coordinator ICT Research
Competence Center Emerging Technologies
Fraunhofer-Institut für System- und Innovationsforschung ISI
Breslauer Straße 48 | 76139 Karlsruhe
fon: +49 721 6809-146 | fax: +49 721 6809-315
assistent: +49 (0) 721/6809-189 (Silke Just)
mailto: michael.friedewald@isi.fraunhofer.de
http://www.isi.fraunhofer.de
http://works.bepress.com/michael_friedewald/
________________________________
Von: bodies.ethics-committee <bodies.ethics-committee-bounces@server.sparta.eu> im Auftrag von Regina Valutytė <r.valutyte@mruni.eu>
Gesendet: Mittwoch, 12. Juni 2019 15:28:43
An: ANTIGNAC Thibaud; bodies.ethics-committee@internal.sparta.eu
Cc: LEMESLE Augustin
Betreff: [SPARTA - bodies.ethics-committee] Ats.: Feedback for D14.1 Dual use aspects draft
Dear Thibaud and Augustin,
I will come back with a feedback tomorrow.
Pagarbiai,
Kind regards,
Regina Valutytė
Vicerektorė akademiniams klausimams
Mykolo Romerio Teisės mokyklos Tarptautinės ir ES teisės Instituto profesorė
Saugumo tyrimų laboratorijos vadovė
Mykolo Romerio universitetas
Vice Rector for academic affairs
Professor, Institute of International and EU law, Mykolas Romeris Law School
Head of Security Research Laboratory
Mykolas Romeris University
Ateities g. 20, LT-08303 Vilnius
Lithuania
________________________________
Nuo: bodies.ethics-committee <bodies.ethics-committee-bounces@server.sparta.eu> ANTIGNAC Thibaud <Thibaud.ANTIGNAC@cea.fr> vardu
Išsiųsta: 2019 m. birželio 12 d., trečiadienis 14:33
Iki: bodies.ethics-committee@internal.sparta.eu
Kopija: LEMESLE Augustin
Tema: [SPARTA - bodies.ethics-committee] Feedback for D14.1 Dual use aspects draft
Dear Ethics Committee,
We made a first draft of D14.1 corresponding to the ethics requirements related to dual-use. It is put in this directory:
https://sparta.technikon.com/03-WPs/WP14-Ethics-requirements/Deliverables/D14.1/
Could you please have a look at it and give your opinion about whether this satisfies the requirements on your opinion (see SPARTA Ethics Summary Report attached)? Any comment, feedback, edits, experience you can share is welcome.
We also plan to contact leaders of the Roadmap, Partnership and Training & Awareness activities along with the 4 programs to ask them whether they identified dual-use items in there are. Do you see any other relevant activity in SPARTA which should be monitored
about this issue? We might wait a couple of days before contacting the leaders to wait for your initial feedback first.
Best regards,
--
Thibaud and Augustin
CEA List